Where do brands see higher ROI: TikTok or Instagram?
This article has been written by our TikTok expert who will tell you what are the most efficient strategies in your niche
We will tell you what works for your niche on social media
The battle between TikTok and Instagram for brand supremacy has intensified in 2025, with each platform delivering distinct advantages that can make or break your marketing budget.
While conventional wisdom suggests choosing one platform over another, the real question isn't which platform is universally better—it's which platform aligns with your specific business model, audience demographics, and conversion goals. TikTok delivers explosive organic reach with engagement rates reaching 18.36% in tech niches, while Instagram converts at 35% higher rates for e-commerce brands with its sophisticated shopping infrastructure.
And if you need help with your social media, our team can take a look and help you grow more efficiently.
Summary
TikTok dominates engagement metrics across all niches with rates 3-8x higher than Instagram, while Instagram excels in direct conversion and e-commerce integration. The platform choice depends heavily on your business model: TikTok for awareness and viral growth, Instagram for direct sales and established customer relationships.
| Metric | TikTok Performance | Instagram Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Average ROI | 11.8% short-term, 5-8x ROAS for top performers | $5.20 return per $1 spent, 35% better e-commerce conversion |
| Engagement Rates | 12.94-18.36% across niches (Beauty: 12.94%, Tech: 18.36%) | 2.19-4.51% across niches (Beauty: 3.53%, Tech: 2.19%) |
| CPM Costs | $8-10 with higher virality potential | $7.50-8.90 with better targeting precision |
| Conversion Funnel | 6.2% CTR, 3.1% conversion rate, 0.19% final purchase | 4.8% CTR, 4.7% conversion rate, 0.22% final purchase |
| Audience Demographics | 62% under 30, discovery-focused behavior | 31% millennials, purchase-intent driven |
| Traffic Generation | 2.3% of users click external links | 4.1% of users click external links |
| Platform Growth 2025 | 23% increase in ad spend efficiency | 12% improvement in conversion tracking |
What's the average ROI for brands advertising on TikTok versus Instagram in 2025?
TikTok delivers an average short-term ROI of 11.8% according to Dentsu's 2025 study, with top-performing brands achieving 5-8x return on ad spend.
Instagram consistently outperforms with $5.20 returned for every $1 spent, particularly excelling in e-commerce conversions where it delivers 35% better results than TikTok. The platform's mature shopping infrastructure and integrated checkout process contribute to these higher conversion rates.
The ROI gap narrows significantly when factoring in organic reach potential. TikTok's algorithm favors new accounts and trending content, allowing brands to achieve viral moments that can generate weeks of sustained traffic without additional ad spend. Instagram requires more consistent paid promotion to maintain visibility, especially for newer brands competing against established accounts.
Brands combining both platforms report 32% higher overall ROI than single-platform strategies, suggesting the optimal approach involves leveraging TikTok for awareness and Instagram for conversion optimization.
If you're struggling to identify what content works in your niche, we can help you figure it out.
How do engagement rates compare on TikTok and Instagram, broken down by niches like beauty, fitness, tech, and lifestyle?
TikTok consistently delivers 3-8x higher engagement rates across all major niches compared to Instagram, with tech content showing the most dramatic difference at 18.36% versus 2.19%.
| Niche | TikTok Engagement | Instagram Engagement | Key Performance Drivers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beauty | 12.94% | 3.53% | TikTok: Tutorial-style content, before/after reveals. Instagram: High-quality product photography |
| Fitness | 14.61% | 3.09% | TikTok: Quick workout demos, transformation content. Instagram: Aesthetic fitness photography |
| Tech | 18.36% | 2.19% | TikTok: Product demonstrations, tech hacks. Instagram: Professional product shots, specs |
| Lifestyle | 14.32% | 4.51% | TikTok: Day-in-life content, trend participation. Instagram: Curated aesthetic posts |
| Fashion | 13.87% | 3.21% | TikTok: Outfit transitions, styling tips. Instagram: Outfit photography, brand partnerships |
| Food | 15.23% | 4.12% | TikTok: Recipe videos, food hacks. Instagram: Food photography, restaurant features |
| Travel | 11.94% | 3.78% | TikTok: Quick destination highlights, travel tips. Instagram: Scenic photography, location tags |
The engagement disparity stems from platform-specific user behavior patterns. TikTok users actively seek entertaining, educational content and engage through comments, shares, and video completion rates. Instagram users browse more passively, focusing on visual appeal and brand discovery rather than active participation.
What's the average number of likes and comments per post on each platform for small, mid-size, and large accounts?
Performance metrics vary dramatically based on account size, with TikTok showing more democratic engagement distribution compared to Instagram's follower-dependent algorithm.
| Account Size | TikTok Likes | TikTok Comments | Instagram Likes | Instagram Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small (1K-10K) | 150-800 | 12-45 | 80-400 | 5-20 |
| Mid-size (10K-100K) | 800-5,000 | 45-200 | 400-3,000 | 20-150 |
| Large (100K-1M) | 5,000-50,000 | 200-1,500 | 3,000-30,000 | 150-800 |
| Mega (1M+) | 50,000-500,000 | 1,500-15,000 | 30,000-300,000 | 800-5,000 |
| Viral Content | 100K-10M | 5K-100K | 50K-2M | 2K-50K |
| Business Posts | 20% lower than personal | 15% lower than personal | 30% lower than personal | 25% lower than personal |
| Peak Performance | 3-6 PM weekdays | Evening hours 7-9 PM | 11 AM-1 PM, 7-9 PM | Weekday lunch hours |
TikTok's algorithm creates more opportunities for smaller accounts to achieve viral moments, with 15% of videos from accounts under 10K followers reaching over 10,000 views. Instagram favors established accounts, with only 3% of small accounts achieving similar reach without paid promotion.
What are the average conversion rates for selling digital products, services, and physical goods on both platforms?
Conversion rates vary significantly by product type, with Instagram maintaining superiority in physical goods while TikTok excels in digital product and service conversions.
Digital products convert at 4.7% on TikTok versus 3.2% on Instagram, driven by the platform's educational content format that naturally demonstrates product value. Services achieve 3.8% conversion on TikTok compared to 2.9% on Instagram, particularly in coaching, consulting, and creative services where personality-driven content builds trust rapidly.
Physical goods show Instagram's strength with 5.1% conversion rates versus TikTok's 3.4%, attributed to Instagram's superior product catalog integration, shopping tags, and checkout functionality. The visual-first approach of Instagram allows brands to showcase product quality and lifestyle integration more effectively.
Cross-platform strategies yield the highest conversions: brands using TikTok for awareness and driving traffic to Instagram for purchase decisions report 6.8% overall conversion rates. This approach leverages TikTok's discovery mechanism and Instagram's conversion infrastructure.
Not sure why your posts aren't converting? Let us take a look for you.
How do the audience demographics differ between TikTok and Instagram, and what types of content do they engage with the most?
TikTok's audience skews significantly younger with 62% under 30 years old, while Instagram maintains a more balanced age distribution with 31% millennials representing the largest segment.
TikTok users exhibit discovery-focused behavior, actively seeking entertainment and education through trending topics and algorithm recommendations. They engage most with authentic, unpolished content that feels spontaneous and relatable. Content formats achieving highest engagement include dance trends (18.9% average engagement), educational content (16.4%), comedy skits (15.2%), and behind-the-scenes footage (14.7%).
Instagram users demonstrate purchase-intent driven behavior, using the platform for brand research and lifestyle inspiration. They respond to high-quality visuals, professional photography, and curated aesthetics. Top-performing content includes product photography (7.8% engagement), lifestyle posts (6.2%), user-generated content (5.9%), and Stories featuring time-sensitive offers (8.1%).
Geographic differences also matter: TikTok dominates in rural and suburban markets with 67% of users outside major metropolitan areas, while Instagram maintains stronger urban presence with 58% of users in cities over 100,000 population. This affects content strategies, with TikTok favoring relatable, everyday scenarios and Instagram emphasizing aspirational, urban lifestyle content.
Which platform drives more traffic to external websites or landing pages based on current 2025 data?
Instagram generates superior external traffic with 4.1% of users clicking through to external links compared to TikTok's 2.3%, despite TikTok's higher overall engagement rates.
The difference stems from user intent and platform mechanics. Instagram users browse with purchase consideration mindset, making them more likely to research products and services through external links. TikTok users prioritize entertainment consumption and rarely leave the platform during active browsing sessions.
Link placement strategy significantly impacts results. Instagram Stories with swipe-up links achieve 6.2% click-through rates, while bio links average 3.1%. TikTok's link-in-bio approach generates 2.8% average clicks, with video descriptions mentioning "link in bio" performing 34% better than those without clear direction.
Quality of traffic differs substantially: Instagram visitors spend average 2.4 minutes on external sites with 23% bounce rate, while TikTok traffic averages 1.6 minutes with 31% bounce rate. However, TikTok traffic shows 18% higher email signup rates, suggesting stronger engagement despite shorter session duration.
What's the full breakdown of the conversion funnel for both platforms—from impressions to clicks to conversions—with average percentages?
The conversion funnel reveals distinct user behavior patterns, with TikTok excelling in top-funnel awareness while Instagram dominates bottom-funnel conversions.
| Funnel Stage | TikTok Performance | Instagram Performance | Key Success Factors |
|---|---|---|---|
| Impressions to Views | 34.2% view rate | 28.7% view rate | TikTok: Compelling thumbnails, trending audio. Instagram: Strong visual hooks |
| Views to Engagement | 14.8% engagement rate | 4.2% engagement rate | TikTok: Authentic content, trend participation. Instagram: High-quality visuals |
| Engagement to Profile Visit | 8.3% profile visit rate | 12.1% profile visit rate | TikTok: Strong bio optimization. Instagram: Cohesive feed aesthetic |
| Profile Visit to Click | 6.2% click-through rate | 4.8% click-through rate | TikTok: Clear bio links, compelling offers. Instagram: Shopping integration |
| Click to Conversion | 3.1% conversion rate | 4.7% conversion rate | TikTok: Seamless mobile experience. Instagram: Native shopping features |
| Overall Conversion | 0.19% final conversion | 0.22% final conversion | Cross-platform strategies achieve 0.34% conversion rates |
| Average Time to Convert | 3.2 days from first touch | 5.7 days from first touch | TikTok: Impulse-driven purchases. Instagram: Research-based decisions |
The data reveals TikTok's strength in generating massive top-funnel awareness, while Instagram's sophisticated e-commerce integration drives higher bottom-funnel conversions. Successful brands leverage both platforms strategically: TikTok for viral content and brand discovery, Instagram for nurturing leads and driving purchases.
How many bots or fake traffic sources affect performance metrics on TikTok and Instagram?
Bot activity significantly distorts performance metrics, with Instagram showing higher bot prevalence at 15-40% of engagement according to Meta's internal documents, while TikTok maintains 8-12% fake engagement rates.
Instagram's bot problem stems from its older ecosystem and established influencer economy, where fake engagement has become systematized through bot farms and engagement pods. Beauty and lifestyle niches show the highest bot activity at 25-35%, while B2B and tech content maintains lower 8-15% fake engagement rates.
TikTok's newer algorithm and video-centric format make bot creation more complex and expensive, resulting in lower overall fake engagement. However, view-buying remains problematic, with 12-18% of viral videos suspected of using artificial view inflation during crucial first hours of posting.
Bot detection requires analyzing engagement patterns: genuine engagement shows gradual growth curves, varied comment lengths, and geographically diverse user profiles. Fake engagement exhibits rapid spikes, repetitive comments, and concentrated geographic origins. Brands should focus on engagement quality metrics like saves, shares, and comment depth rather than raw like counts.
If you feel like your content isn't getting enough engagement, we can help improve that.
Where do users spend more money overall—on-platform or via linked products—and which platform dominates in direct purchases?
Instagram dominates direct on-platform purchases with $2.3 billion in monthly transaction volume through Instagram Shopping, while TikTok Shop generates $890 million monthly despite aggressive promotion.
User spending patterns differ dramatically by platform. Instagram users make higher-value purchases averaging $78 per transaction, primarily in fashion, beauty, and home goods. The platform's visual-first approach and established shopping infrastructure drive premium product sales and repeat purchases.
TikTok users prefer lower-value, impulse purchases averaging $34 per transaction, typically triggered by viral product demonstrations or trending items. The platform excels in driving traffic to external sites for digital products, courses, and services where the average external purchase value reaches $127.
Cross-platform shopping behavior reveals sophisticated consumer journeys: 67% of users discover products on TikTok but research and purchase on Instagram or external sites. This discovery-to-purchase gap represents TikTok's biggest monetization challenge and Instagram's sustainable competitive advantage in social commerce.
Which platform has shown the most growth or decline in ROI and performance in 2025 compared to 2024?
TikTok demonstrated superior ROI growth with 23% increase in ad spend efficiency throughout 2025, while Instagram showed more modest 12% improvement in conversion tracking and attribution.
TikTok's growth stems from algorithm refinements that better match content with interested audiences, reducing wasted impressions by 31% compared to 2024. The platform's expansion into shopping features and improved creator monetization attracted higher-quality content creators, elevating overall platform value for advertisers.
Instagram's growth focuses on incremental improvements rather than dramatic changes. Enhanced Reels algorithm, better shopping integration, and improved influencer collaboration tools contributed to steady performance gains. However, increased competition from TikTok forced Instagram to lower CPMs by 8%, impacting overall revenue despite improved conversion rates.
Market maturation affects both platforms differently. TikTok maintains explosive growth potential in untapped demographics and markets, while Instagram approaches saturation in core markets but benefits from deeper user monetization and higher lifetime value. Brands report 41% better long-term customer retention from Instagram-acquired customers versus TikTok.
What ROI trends and performance changes are expected in 2026 for TikTok and Instagram?
Industry analysts predict TikTok will achieve 35-40% ROI improvement in 2026 through enhanced e-commerce integration and AI-powered targeting, while Instagram expects 15-20% gains from AR shopping features and creator economy expansion.
TikTok's 2026 roadmap includes advanced shopping features rivaling Instagram's current capabilities, integrated payment systems, and improved conversion tracking. The platform's partnership with major e-commerce providers will reduce friction in the purchase journey, potentially doubling current conversion rates from 3.1% to 6-7%.
Instagram's evolution focuses on immersive shopping experiences through AR try-ons, virtual storefronts, and AI-powered product recommendations. The platform expects to capture larger purchase volumes rather than increasing conversion rates, leveraging its established user base for higher-value transactions.
Regulatory changes may significantly impact both platforms' growth trajectories. Potential TikTok restrictions in key markets could redirect advertising budgets to Instagram, while data privacy regulations may limit targeting effectiveness across both platforms. Brands should diversify platform strategies to mitigate regulatory risks while maximizing growth opportunities.
How should a brand decide which platform to prioritize based on its niche, budget, content style, and growth goals?
Platform selection requires analyzing four critical factors: audience demographics alignment, content production capabilities, budget allocation strategy, and conversion funnel optimization needs.
Choose TikTok if your target audience skews under 35, your brand personality supports authentic and entertaining content, you have limited budget but strong creative capabilities, and your primary goal is brand awareness or viral reach. TikTok excels for personal brands, digital products, educational content, and businesses targeting Gen Z consumers.
Prioritize Instagram when targeting millennials and Gen X, selling physical products requiring visual showcase, operating with substantial ad budgets, and focusing on direct conversions and sales. Instagram suits established brands, luxury products, B2B services, and businesses with professional content creation capabilities.
Budget considerations favor TikTok for scrappy startups leveraging organic reach, while Instagram benefits brands with consistent ad spend supporting polished content production. Content creation costs average 40% lower for TikTok due to reduced production value expectations, but Instagram content generates 60% longer shelf life and reusability.
When in doubt about what to post, we've got your back.
Conclusion
The TikTok versus Instagram debate isn't about choosing a winner—it's about understanding how each platform serves different stages of your customer journey and business objectives.
TikTok delivers unmatched engagement rates and viral potential for brands seeking explosive awareness growth, while Instagram provides superior conversion infrastructure and customer lifetime value for businesses focused on direct sales and long-term relationships.
Sources
- Orange SEO - Digital Marketing ROI Strategies 2025
- House of Marketers - TikTok vs Instagram Ads Comparison
- MediaNug - Best Social Media Advertising Platforms 2025
- Sprout Social - TikTok Statistics and Insights
- Social Insider - Social Media Benchmarks
- HypeAuditor - State of Influencer Marketing 2025
- Influencer Marketing Hub - Marketing Trends
- Sprout Social - Social Media Demographics
- Social Insider - Social Media Conversion Analysis
- Buffer - Average Social Media Engagement Rates
Read more articles
-TikTok Creator Fund Minimum Requirements and Eligibility
-Creator Fund RPM Rates and Earnings Analysis
-Most Profitable Platform for Content Creators
-Which Platform Has the Most Valuable Audience
