Which type of audience is more valuable: TikTok’s or Instagram’s?
This article has been written by our TikTok expert who will tell you what are the most efficient strategies in your niche
We will tell you what works for your niche on social media
The battle between TikTok and Instagram for creator attention and brand investment has reached a critical point in 2025, with both platforms offering distinct advantages for audience monetization.
Understanding which platform delivers more valuable audiences requires examining engagement rates, conversion metrics, demographics, and revenue potential across different creator tiers and business models. And if you need help with your social media, our team can take a look and help you grow more efficiently.
Summary
TikTok consistently outperforms Instagram in engagement rates (2.88-7.50% vs 1.77-3.65%) and drives superior viral reach, while Instagram excels in revenue per follower and conversion rates for established brands.
| Metric | TikTok | |
|---|---|---|
| Engagement Rate | 2.88-7.50% (depends on follower count), educational accounts reach 9.5% | 1.77-3.65% (depends on follower count), construction/nonprofit lead at 2.6% |
| Daily Time Spent | 58.4 minutes (US), up to 95 minutes globally, average session 11 minutes | 30 minutes globally, average session 2 minutes 44 seconds |
| Primary Demographics | 55% users 18-34, discovery-focused, trend-driven behavior | 60% users 18-34, polished content preference, higher purchase intent |
| Conversion Rates | 2-2.5% average, up to 30% during live streams, excels at viral/impulse buys | 3-3.5% average for product links, 29% of users make purchases directly |
| Revenue Model | Lower CPM but higher volume, live shopping, viral product launches | Higher revenue per follower, mature shopping features, brand partnerships |
| Content Strength | Viral reach, authentic/raw content, trend marketing, younger demographics | Brand loyalty, storytelling, DMs/private engagement, cross-platform integration |
| Fake Engagement | 10-20% fake followers average (15% typical), impacts larger accounts more | 5-15% fake followers average (10% typical), brands audit more frequently |
What are the current engagement rates on TikTok and Instagram in 2025 by follower count and niche?
TikTok maintains its position as the engagement powerhouse with rates consistently outperforming Instagram across all account sizes.
| Follower Range | TikTok Engagement Rate | Instagram Engagement Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Under 10K | 7.5% - 10% (nano-influencers can reach 14.6% in fitness) | 4% - 8% (varies significantly by content quality) |
| 10K - 100K | 5% - 7% (micro-influencers maintain strong engagement) | 2% - 4% (decline more pronounced than TikTok) |
| 100K - 500K | 4.5% - 5.2% (still maintaining decent engagement) | 1.5% - 3% (significant drop from smaller accounts) |
| 500K - 1M | 4.4% (macro-influencers face challenges but remain viable) | 1% - 2% (engagement becomes increasingly difficult) |
| 1M+ | 2.8% - 3.7% (mega-influencers still outperform Instagram) | <1% - 2% (most struggle to maintain meaningful engagement) |
By niche, TikTok's educational content leads at 9.5% engagement, followed by food and drink (6-8%), while beauty and fashion see lower rates (2.5-4%). Instagram's construction and nonprofit sectors achieve 2.6% engagement on Reels, while higher education reaches 2.4%.
The engagement gap between platforms has widened in 2025, with Instagram experiencing a 28% year-over-year decline while TikTok only dropped 5.6%, cementing TikTok's dominance in organic reach and interaction.
How do likes and comments per post compare between TikTok and Instagram across different account sizes?
TikTok consistently generates higher absolute engagement numbers per post, particularly in comments and shares, which indicate deeper audience connection.
For accounts with 1K-5K followers, TikTok posts average 320 likes compared to Instagram's 100-400 range. This gap widens significantly at higher follower counts, with 50K-100K TikTok accounts receiving 2,000+ likes per post versus Instagram's approximately 1,500.
Comments represent the most telling difference - TikTok's comment-driven culture generates substantially more discussion per post than Instagram's more passive double-tap behavior. TikTok's algorithm actively rewards comment engagement, creating viral conversations that Instagram's reach-focused algorithm doesn't replicate.
Share rates on TikTok dramatically exceed Instagram's, with viral potential being a key differentiator. A single TikTok video can accumulate hundreds of thousands of shares, while Instagram's sharing primarily occurs through private DMs or Stories, limiting viral reach.
Which platform delivers higher conversion rates for different product types and business models?
Instagram maintains superiority for considered purchases and established brands, while TikTok excels at impulse buying and viral product launches.
Instagram achieves 3-3.5% average conversion rates for direct product links, particularly strong for fashion, beauty, and lifestyle brands with established reputations. The platform's shopping integration and longer content formats allow for detailed product showcases that build purchase confidence.
TikTok averages 2-2.5% for standard product links but shines during live commerce sessions, where conversion rates spike to 9-30%. This creates unique opportunities for real-time sales but requires specific content strategies and timing.
For affiliate marketing, TikTok generates 5-30% engagement rates for creators under 100K followers, while Instagram provides more consistent 3-5% click-through rates through Stories and bio links. The key difference lies in TikTok's viral potential versus Instagram's predictable performance.
Digital products and services perform better on Instagram due to the platform's mature audience and detailed content capabilities, while physical products benefit from TikTok's discovery-driven shopping behavior and impulse purchase mentality.
What are the key demographic and behavioral differences between TikTok and Instagram audiences in 2025?
Both platforms attract primarily 18-34 year olds, but user behavior and content consumption patterns differ significantly.
| Aspect | TikTok | |
|---|---|---|
| Age Distribution | 30.7% ages 18-24 (US), strong Gen Z presence, expanding to older demographics | 31.7% ages 18-24, more balanced across age groups, stronger 25-34 segment |
| Gender Split | 55% male, 45% female globally (varies by region) | 50.6% male, 49.4% female (very balanced distribution) |
| User Behavior | Discovery-focused, trend-driven, high interaction, rapid content consumption | Following-based, aspirational content, private engagement (DMs/saves), research-oriented |
| Content Preference | Raw, authentic, trend-based videos, challenges, educational content | Polished visuals, Stories, Reels, carousel posts, influencer content |
| Purchase Journey | Impulse-driven, product discovery through trends, live shopping engagement | Research-oriented, brand consideration, shopping tags and links integration |
TikTok users open the app 19 times daily with 11-minute sessions, demonstrating intensive engagement patterns. Instagram users average longer total daily time (30 minutes) but in shorter, more frequent sessions (2 minutes 44 seconds).
The psychological difference is crucial: TikTok users seek entertainment and discovery, while Instagram users engage in social connection and aspiration, affecting how brands should approach each platform's audience.
Which platform generates more revenue per follower and how does this vary by niche?
Instagram consistently delivers higher revenue per follower across most niches, while TikTok compensates with higher volume and viral potential.
Fashion and beauty creators earn $8-18 CPM on Instagram Reels, with mid-tier creators commanding up to $8,000 per sponsored post. TikTok's lower CPM is offset by live shopping capabilities, where streamers earn $30-80 per hour in gifts plus commission on sales.
Business and finance content performs exceptionally well on Instagram due to the platform's mature audience and higher income demographics. TikTok excels in gaming, food, and lifestyle niches where viral moments can generate massive exposure quickly.
Micro-influencers (10K-50K followers) often see better monetization rates on TikTok due to higher engagement ratios, while macro-influencers benefit from Instagram's established brand partnership ecosystem and premium advertising rates.
The fitness niche shows particularly strong performance on TikTok with 14.6% engagement rates for nano-influencers, creating lucrative opportunities for supplement brands and workout programs targeting younger demographics.
How much time do users spend per session on each platform and what are the video completion rates?
TikTok dominates in session length and total daily usage, creating superior opportunities for content consumption and brand exposure.
TikTok users spend 58.4 minutes daily in the US (up to 95 minutes globally) across an average of 19 daily sessions lasting 11 minutes each. This intensive usage pattern provides multiple touchpoints for brand messaging throughout the day.
Instagram users spend approximately 30 minutes daily in much shorter sessions averaging 2 minutes 44 seconds. While total time is lower, Instagram's cross-platform integration with Facebook and WhatsApp extends overall brand exposure across Meta's ecosystem.
Video completion rates favor TikTok significantly, with 60-80% completion rates for short-form content versus Instagram's lower engagement on video posts. TikTok's algorithm optimizes for watch time, encouraging creators to maintain viewer attention throughout entire videos.
The addictive nature of TikTok's "For You Page" creates longer browsing sessions, while Instagram's feed and Stories encourage quick check-ins and targeted engagement with specific accounts or hashtags.
How has audience performance evolved in 2025 for engagement, reach, and conversion?
Both platforms experienced engagement declines in 2025, but TikTok's drop was minimal compared to Instagram's significant decrease.
TikTok's engagement fell only 5.6% year-over-year (from 2.65% to 2.50%), while Instagram experienced a dramatic 28% decline (from 0.70% to 0.50%). This shift indicates Instagram's algorithm increasingly prioritizes reach over deep engagement.
Reach performance shows TikTok maintaining strong discovery capabilities through its For You Page, while Instagram's reach depends heavily on existing followers and hashtag optimization. Organic reach on Instagram requires more strategic content planning and community building.
Conversion tracking has improved on both platforms, with TikTok Shop integration driving direct sales and Instagram's shopping features becoming more sophisticated. However, iOS privacy changes affected both platforms' tracking capabilities, requiring first-party data strategies.
If you're struggling to identify what content works in your niche, we can help you figure it out.
What are the projected trends for 2026 regarding audience growth, monetization, and creator support?
TikTok is expected to continue rapid growth among Gen Z and young Millennials, while Instagram maintains broader but slower growth across age groups.
Monetization evolution will see Instagram expanding subscription and advanced shop features, while TikTok focuses on live commerce, affiliate programs, and premium content options. Both platforms are investing heavily in AI tools for content creation and audience targeting.
Creator support programs will prioritize micro-influencers and authentic content creators over celebrity partnerships. Brands are shifting budgets toward creators with smaller but highly engaged audiences who demonstrate genuine product affinity.
Cross-platform strategies will become essential, with successful creators using TikTok for discovery and viral growth, then monetizing deeper relationships on Instagram through longer-form content and direct shopping integrations.
Privacy regulations and iOS tracking limitations will drive both platforms toward first-party data collection and on-platform conversion optimization, benefiting creators who can drive direct sales rather than external traffic.
What percentage of fake followers affects each platform and how does this impact revenue?
Fake follower percentages differ between platforms, with TikTok showing higher rates but Instagram facing more scrutiny from brands.
TikTok averages 10-20% fake followers (typically 15%), with higher rates affecting larger accounts more severely. The platform's rapid growth and algorithm-driven discovery make it easier for fake accounts to gain traction without detection.
Instagram shows 5-15% fake followers (typically 10%), but brands increasingly audit influencer authenticity before partnerships. Instagram's longer history and more mature verification systems provide better fake account detection.
Revenue impact is significant for both platforms - fake followers dilute engagement rates and reduce actual conversion potential. Brands are shifting toward micro-influencers with verified audiences rather than mega-influencers with questionable follower quality.
Detection tools and third-party auditing services have become essential for brand partnerships, with many companies requiring follower authenticity verification before campaign approval. This trend benefits creators with organic growth over those who purchased followers.
What does a typical conversion funnel look like on each platform with drop-off rates?
TikTok and Instagram employ different funnel strategies based on their unique user behaviors and platform strengths.
TikTok's funnel: Reach (For You Page/viral/trending) → Engagement (likes/comments/shares) → Click-through (bio links/TikTok Shop) → Purchase. Drop-off rates are high at click-through for standard posts but extremely low during live shopping events where real-time interaction drives immediate purchases.
Instagram's funnel: Reach (Reels/Explore/Stories/Feed) → Engagement (likes/comments/saves/DMs) → Click-through (shopping tags/story links/bio) → Purchase. Lower drop-off at click-through due to better shopping integration, but higher conversion rates for established brands with trust signals.
Live commerce on TikTok creates unique funnel acceleration, with viewers making impulse purchases during streams without traditional consideration phases. Instagram's funnel accommodates longer research periods through saved posts and DM conversations.
Cross-platform funnels are becoming common, with creators using TikTok for awareness and Instagram for conversion, leveraging each platform's strengths in the customer journey.
In which specific scenarios does TikTok clearly win versus when Instagram is superior?
Each platform dominates specific use cases based on content type, audience behavior, and business objectives.
TikTok excels at viral marketing, trend participation, authentic/raw content, reaching younger demographics (under 25), product discovery, educational content, and live shopping for impulse purchases. The platform's algorithm rewards engaging content regardless of follower count, making it ideal for new creators and viral product launches.
Instagram dominates brand loyalty building, polished visual storytelling, cross-platform integration, targeting 25-44 demographics, affiliate marketing, established brand partnerships, and considered purchases. The platform's mature shopping features and professional creator tools make it superior for sustained business growth.
For customer service and community building, Instagram's DM system and private engagement capabilities outperform TikTok's comment-based interactions. Instagram also provides better analytics and business tools for tracking ROI and audience insights.
Geographic considerations matter - TikTok performs better in markets with younger populations, while Instagram maintains strength in regions with established digital shopping behaviors and higher disposable incomes.
Not sure why your posts aren't converting? Let us take a look for you.
Based on creator goals, how should one decide which platform to prioritize for maximum growth and revenue?
Platform selection should align with content type, target demographics, monetization timeline, and business model preferences.
Choose TikTok if you create short-form, authentic content targeting under-30 demographics, want rapid audience growth, plan to monetize through viral products or live commerce, or operate in trending niches like food, gaming, or education. TikTok suits creators comfortable with constant content creation and trend participation.
Choose Instagram if you produce polished visual content, target 25-44 demographics, want to build long-term brand partnerships, sell higher-priced products or services, or need sophisticated analytics and business tools. Instagram benefits creators focused on professional growth and sustainable monetization.
Dual-platform strategies work best for most creators: use TikTok for rapid growth and viral discovery, then funnel audiences to Instagram for deeper engagement and monetization. This approach maximizes reach while building sustainable revenue streams.
Budget considerations matter - TikTok requires more frequent content creation but lower production costs, while Instagram benefits from higher-quality visuals and strategic posting schedules. Time investment differs significantly between platforms.
Industry-specific recommendations: fitness, beauty, and lifestyle creators benefit from both platforms; business and finance content performs better on Instagram; food, gaming, and entertainment favor TikTok's viral potential.
Conclusion
The choice between TikTok and Instagram audiences ultimately depends on your specific goals, content style, and monetization strategy.
TikTok offers superior engagement rates, longer daily usage, and viral potential that can rapidly scale audiences, making it ideal for creators seeking fast growth and younger demographics. Instagram provides higher revenue per follower, better conversion rates for established brands, and more sophisticated business tools for sustainable monetization.
Sources
- TikTok vs. Instagram: Comparing Average Engagement Rates in 2025 - Influencer Marketing Factory
- 28 TikTok statistics marketers need to know in 2025 | Sprout Social
- Social Media Benchmarks For 2025
- What is a Good Engagement Rate on TikTok for 2025? | Brandwatch
- Instagram Statistics Marketers Should Know in 2025 | Sprout Social
- TikTok User Age, Gender, & Demographics (2025)
- Average Time Spent On TikTok Statistics and Facts (2025)
- TikTok Statistics You Need to Know in 2025
- TikTok Marketing Report 2025 - Key Trends, Statistics, and Insights
- TikTok Ads conversion rate: definition and best practices | DashThis
Read more articles
-Creator Fund Minimum Requirements and Earnings
-Creator Fund RPM Rates and Performance
-Most Profitable Platform for Content Creators
-Which Platform Delivers Higher ROI for Creators
-Highest Revenue Content Types on Instagram
-Best Performing Business Content on TikTok
-Highest Earning Creators on TikTok
-Fastest Growing Accounts on TikTok
-Highest Revenue Content on TikTok
