Today, do you get a better reach on TikTok or on YouTube?

This article has been written by our TikTok expert who will tell you what are the most efficient strategies in your niche

What's the average reach per post on TikTok versus YouTube Shorts in 2025 by account size?

TikTok delivers significantly higher average reach across all account sizes, with smaller accounts often experiencing explosive growth potential.

For accounts under 10K followers, TikTok provides average reach of 2,665-5,000 views per video, while YouTube Shorts typically generates hundreds to low thousands of views for similar account sizes. The TikTok algorithm's emphasis on content quality over follower count means new creators can achieve substantial reach immediately.

Accounts with 10K-100K followers see TikTok reach doubling when crossing follower thresholds, with average views jumping to 10,000-50,000 per post. YouTube Shorts in this range provides more predictable but lower reach, typically 5,000-25,000 views, heavily influenced by existing subscriber engagement and channel authority.

For accounts exceeding 100K followers, TikTok consistently delivers 50,000-500,000+ views per post, while YouTube Shorts provides 25,000-200,000 views. However, YouTube Shorts offers more sustainable reach patterns and better long-term audience retention across all account sizes.

What are the average engagement rates across lifestyle, education, comedy, and product review niches?

Content Niche	TikTok Engagement Rate	YouTube Shorts Engagement Rate
Lifestyle	2.8-4.5% with higher shares due to relatable content and trend participation	6.2-8.1% with strong watch time and subscriber conversion
Education	6-10% for niche accounts with specialized knowledge sharing	8-12% leveraging YouTube's search functionality and evergreen value
Comedy	3.5-7% with high share rates driving algorithmic distribution	5.8-9.2% with strong completion rates and repeat viewing
Product Review	2.2-3.8% with strong conversion potential through TikTok Shop integration	4.5-7.3% with higher trust factors and detailed content appreciation

Educational content performs exceptionally well on both platforms but shows higher engagement rates on YouTube Shorts due to the platform's search functionality and audience expectation for informative content.

How does algorithmic distribution work differently on TikTok versus YouTube Shorts for non-followers?

TikTok's algorithm aggressively pushes content to non-followers, prioritizing immediate virality and rapid audience expansion.

TikTok's For You page algorithm focuses on watch time, completion rate, likes, shares, and engagement velocity to rapidly distribute content beyond your follower base. Videos can reach millions of non-followers within hours if they demonstrate strong initial engagement signals. The platform uses trending sounds, hashtags, and challenges to boost discoverability, often giving new creators equal visibility to established accounts.

YouTube Shorts employs a more conservative, gradual distribution approach that values consistency and connection to existing channel content. The algorithm initially tests content on a small audience segment, often starting with subscribers or users with similar viewing patterns. If performance metrics like watch time and engagement prove positive, the algorithm gradually expands reach to broader non-follower audiences.

TikTok's distribution peaks within 24-48 hours, while YouTube Shorts can gain traction over weeks or months. YouTube integrates Shorts with search results and suggests them alongside long-form content, providing multiple discovery pathways. TikTok prioritizes trend participation and timing, whereas YouTube rewards consistency and niche authority for sustained non-follower reach.

What are the average likes and comments per post for new creators under 10K followers?

New TikTok creators typically achieve higher absolute engagement numbers but YouTube Shorts delivers superior engagement rates relative to audience size.

TikTok creators with under 10K followers average 50-300 likes per post and 5-25 comments, depending on content quality and trend alignment. Nano-influencers often achieve 4-8% engagement rates on TikTok, indicating strong audience interaction despite smaller follower counts. The platform's algorithm can rapidly amplify engaging content, leading to viral moments that generate thousands of likes and hundreds of comments overnight.

YouTube Shorts creators in the same follower range typically receive 25-150 likes per post and 2-15 comments, but maintain higher engagement rates averaging 5.4% overall. The top 10% of new YouTube creators achieve over 10% engagement rates through consistent, quality content production and strategic community building.

YouTube Shorts engagement grows more predictably with channel development, while TikTok engagement can fluctuate dramatically based on algorithmic favor and trend participation. Both platforms reward authentic interaction, but YouTube's engagement tends to be more meaningful for long-term audience building.

If you're struggling to identify what content works in your niche, we can help you figure it out.

How many views are required to gain 1,000 followers on each platform?

Both platforms require approximately 59,000 views to gain 1,000 followers, but the timeline and sustainability differ significantly.

TikTok and YouTube Shorts both average 16.9 subscribers per 10,000 views, translating to roughly 59,000 views needed for 1,000 new followers. However, TikTok can achieve this growth much faster through viral content, potentially gaining 1,000 followers in days if videos trend effectively.

YouTube Shorts followers tend to be more valuable long-term, with 49% of influencers reporting better audience retention compared to TikTok. The platform's integration with broader YouTube features means followers often engage with multiple content types and provide more stable, sustained viewership.

TikTok's follower conversion rate peaks at 6.2% for viral videos but drops significantly for non-viral content. YouTube Shorts maintains steadier conversion rates around 3.9%, providing more predictable growth patterns. The key difference lies in follower quality—YouTube subscribers typically demonstrate higher lifetime value and cross-platform engagement.

What are the current conversion rates for product sales across different product types?

TikTok excels in impulse purchase conversion through native shopping features, while YouTube Shorts drives higher-value, considered purchases through detailed content.

For digital products, TikTok Shop integration enables conversion rates of 8-15% for trending items, with affiliate commissions ranging 5-20%. Educational digital products perform particularly well, often achieving 30-75% commission rates through creator partnerships. TikTok's live shopping events can increase conversion rates by up to 300% through real-time interaction and urgency marketing.

YouTube Shorts conversion rates for digital products average 5-12% but demonstrate higher customer lifetime value. The platform's longer-form content integration allows for detailed product demonstrations and review content that builds trust before purchase. Affiliate marketing performs effectively through video descriptions and channel integration, though requires longer relationship building.

Physical product sales on TikTok benefit from viral demonstrations and personalized recommendation algorithms, achieving 6-12% conversion rates for trending items. YouTube Shorts physical product conversions average 4-8% but result in higher average order values due to detailed content and established creator trust. Both platforms show strong performance in beauty, fashion, and lifestyle product categories.

What percentage of traffic comes from bots or fake views, especially on newer accounts?

TikTok faces significant bot traffic challenges with up to 75-97% fake clicks on ads, while YouTube Shorts employs more sophisticated detection systems.

TikTok removed 6 billion fake followers in Q4 2024 alone, indicating widespread bot activity affecting platform metrics. Studies show 75-97% of ad clicks on TikTok can originate from bots, particularly impacting newer accounts and advertiser campaigns. This bot traffic inflates view counts but leads to lower genuine engagement rates and potential shadow banning for accounts using artificial growth methods.

YouTube Shorts benefits from Google's advanced AI detection systems that identify and remove bot views more effectively. While view botting exists, YouTube's algorithm quickly identifies artificial engagement patterns and penalizes offending channels. The platform's detection reduces bot impact over time, though initial fake views can still distort early performance metrics.

New accounts on both platforms are particularly vulnerable to bot inflation, but the consequences differ. TikTok's algorithm may initially boost artificially inflated content before detecting manipulation, while YouTube's system tends to catch fake engagement earlier in the distribution process. Authentic growth strategies remain more sustainable on both platforms despite bot challenges.

Not sure why your posts aren't converting? Let us take a look for you.

What content types perform best for engagement and conversions on each platform?

TikTok thrives on fast-paced, trend-driven content that encourages immediate action, while YouTube Shorts rewards educational and evergreen content that builds sustained audience relationships.

TikTok's highest-performing content includes:

• Viral challenges and trend participation with trending sounds and effects
• Quick product demonstrations with storytelling elements under 30 seconds
• Duets and stitches that engage with existing viral content
• Behind-the-scenes content that feels authentic and unpolished
• User-generated content collaborations that build community trust

YouTube Shorts excels with:

• Educational tutorials and how-to content that provides immediate value
• Detailed product reviews and comparison content
• Behind-the-scenes content that complements longer-form videos
• Content that funnels viewers to full-length videos and builds channel loyalty
• Search-optimized content targeting specific keywords and problems

For conversions, TikTok's authentic storytelling and impulse-driven format generates immediate sales, while YouTube's detailed content builds trust that leads to higher-value purchases over time.

How does average session time affect content visibility on each platform?

TikTok's extended session times boost video completion rates and algorithmic promotion, while YouTube Shorts leverages platform-wide watch time for enhanced visibility.

TikTok users spend an average of 95 minutes daily on the platform, creating extended browsing sessions that favor content appearing early in user feeds. The platform's algorithm uses session duration as a key ranking factor—videos that maintain user attention and encourage continued scrolling receive substantial algorithmic boosts.

YouTube Shorts benefits from the platform's overall high watch time, though specific Shorts session data isn't separately reported. The algorithm values video completion rates and retention, with longer Shorts (up to 3 minutes) performing well when they maintain high retention rates throughout the extended duration.

Session time directly impacts algorithmic distribution on both platforms. TikTok prioritizes content that keeps users engaged in continuous scrolling sessions, while YouTube focuses on individual video completion rates and cross-content engagement. Videos that encourage viewers to stay on the platform longer receive priority placement in both algorithms.

What does the complete funnel look like from impressions to purchases?

Funnel Stage	TikTok Performance	YouTube Shorts Performance
Impressions	High through viral algorithm and For You page distribution	Steady through subscriber base, search, and suggested videos
Engagement	Likes, comments, shares, duets, stitches drive rapid amplification	Likes, comments, shares, subscriptions build channel authority
Profile Visits	High due to quick content discovery and impulse following	Moderate, linked to channel subscriptions and content depth
External Clicks	Bio links, TikTok Shop, and direct purchase features	Video descriptions, cards, end screens, and integrated ads
Purchases	High conversion via TikTok Shop, affiliate links, and impulse buying	Moderate conversion driven by trust, detailed content, and consideration

TikTok's funnel optimizes for speed and impulse decisions, while YouTube Shorts builds trust and consideration throughout the customer journey for higher-value conversions.

How have reach, engagement, and monetization evolved on both platforms in 2025?

TikTok engagement has declined slightly to 2.5% but maintains platform leadership, while YouTube Shorts engagement has grown to 5.9% with enhanced monetization options.

TikTok's engagement rates dropped from 2.65% in 2023 to 2.5% in 2024-2025, though the platform remains the most engaging social media platform overall. The decline reflects increased competition and algorithm changes, but TikTok still outperforms Instagram (0.50%) and other platforms significantly. User growth continues globally, reaching over 766 million monthly users in China alone.

YouTube Shorts has shown remarkable growth with engagement rates increasing to 5.9% in 2025, nearly double TikTok's rates. The platform's total watch time increased 65% year-over-year, with 72% of YouTube users watching Shorts weekly. This growth reflects improved algorithm performance and better creator tools.

Monetization has evolved dramatically on both platforms. TikTok launched its Creativity Program Beta replacing the old Creator Fund, offering $0.40-$1.20 RPM for videos over one minute. YouTube Shorts enhanced its Partner Program, providing $0.80-$2.50 RPM with 45% revenue sharing compared to TikTok's 22%. YouTube's monetization stability attracts creators seeking reliable income streams.

If you feel like your content isn't getting enough engagement, we can help improve that.

How should creators choose between platforms based on their 2026 goals?

Creator Goal	Recommended Platform	Strategic Reasoning
Brand Building	TikTok Primary	Fast virality, trend-driven exposure, younger audience engagement, strong community building through challenges and duets
Affiliate Marketing	TikTok Primary	Seamless shopping integration, higher impulse purchase rates, viral product demonstrations, TikTok Shop native features
Digital Product Sales	Both Platforms	YouTube for evergreen educational content and trust building; TikTok for awareness and trend-based promotion
Virality Focus	TikTok Primary	Algorithm favors rapid exposure, trend participation opportunities, equal visibility for new creators
Sustainable Income	YouTube Shorts	Superior monetization rates ($0.80-$2.50 RPM vs $0.40-$1.20), 45% revenue sharing, evergreen content potential
Long-term Growth	YouTube Shorts	Search integration, content longevity, cross-platform ecosystem, higher audience retention rates
Educational Content	YouTube Shorts	Search discoverability, evergreen value, audience expects informative content, higher engagement rates for education

Most successful creators in 2026 should consider a dual-platform strategy, leveraging TikTok for rapid audience building and trend participation while using YouTube Shorts for monetization and long-term sustainability.

Conclusion

Sources

1. Zebracat - YouTube Shorts Statistics 2025
2. Sprout Social - TikTok Statistics 2025
3. Social Insider - TikTok vs Reels vs Shorts Study
4. Adam Connell - YouTube Shorts Statistics
5. Single Grain - YouTube Shorts vs TikTok 2025
6. Vocal Media - TikTok vs YouTube Shorts Monetization
7. Delivered Social - TikTok vs YouTube 2025
8. Brandwatch - TikTok Engagement Rate Guide
9. Metricool - YouTube Shorts Algorithm Guide
10. Sprout Social - TikTok Algorithm Guide

Who is the author of this content?

NAPOLIFY

A team specialized in data-driven growth strategies for social media

We offer data-driven, battle-tested approach to growing online profiles, especially on platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook. Unlike traditional agencies or consultants who often recycle generic advice,we go on the field and we keep analyzing real-world social content—breaking down hundreds of viral posts to identify what formats, hooks, and strategies actually drive engagement, conversions, and growth. If you'd like to learn more about us, you can check our website.

How this content was created 🔎📝

At Napolify, we analyze social media trends and viral content every day. Our team doesn't just observe from a distance—we're actively studying platform-specific patterns, breaking down viral posts, and maintaining a constantly updated database of trends, tactics, and strategies. This hands-on approach allows us to understand what actually drives engagement and growth.

These observations are originally based on what we've learned through analyzing hundreds of viral posts and real-world performance data. But it was not enough. To back them up, we also needed to rely on trusted resources and case studies from major brands.

We prioritize accuracy and authority. Trends lacking solid data or performance metrics were excluded.

Trustworthiness is central to our work. Every source and citation is clearly listed, ensuring transparency. A writing AI-powered tool was used solely to refine readability and engagement.

To make the information accessible, our team designed custom infographics that clarify key points. We hope you will like them! All illustrations and media were created in-house and added manually.