Today, do you get a better engagement rate on TikTok or on Instagram?

This article has been written by our TikTok expert who will tell you what are the most efficient strategies in your niche

Calculate your TikTok
Creator Reward Earnings

Use our free tool and get a very accurate result.

CALCULATE

What's the average engagement rate on TikTok versus Instagram in 2025 across all industries?

TikTok maintains a 2.50% average engagement rate while Instagram has dropped to 0.50% in 2025.

Instagram experienced a significant 28% year-over-year decline in engagement rates, reflecting increased competition and algorithm changes that favor paid content. TikTok's algorithm continues prioritizing organic reach, maintaining engagement levels between 1.0% and 7.5% depending on the niche.

The 5× engagement advantage stems from TikTok's feed algorithm that pushes content based on interest signals rather than follower relationships. Instagram's shift toward commercial content has diluted organic reach, with only 6.5% of followers typically seeing unpaid posts. TikTok users spend 95 minutes daily on the platform compared to Instagram's 53 minutes, creating more opportunities for engagement.

Platform maturity also affects these numbers. Instagram's 14-year history has created content saturation, while TikTok's relative newness (globally launched in 2018) maintains novelty factor driving higher interaction rates.

These industry-wide averages hide significant niche variations, with entertainment content performing exceptionally well on TikTok while educational content shows stronger performance on Instagram.

How do engagement rates compare by niche—like fashion, fitness, education, or comedy—on each platform?

Entertainment and fitness content dominate TikTok engagement, while education performs better on Instagram's format-diverse ecosystem.

Niche	TikTok Engagement Rate	Instagram Engagement Rate
Comedy/Entertainment	9.1% - High viral potential, algorithm favors humor	1.2% - Limited by feed saturation
Fitness	7.2% - Transformation content performs well	2.1% - Before/after posts drive engagement
Food	8.4% - Recipe videos and food hacks viral	3.5% - Visual appeal strong in feed
Fashion	6.8% - Outfit transitions and styling tips	1.9% - Declining despite visual nature
Education	4.5% - Quick tips and hacks format	3.8% - Carousel posts excel for tutorials
Beauty	5.9% - Makeup tutorials and reviews	2.4% - Influencer saturation impact
Business/Finance	3.8% - Younger audience engagement	2.9% - Professional content performs

How do average likes and comments per post differ for micro, mid, and macro influencers on TikTok and Instagram?

Nano influencers achieve dramatically higher engagement rates on both platforms, with TikTok showing 2-3× better performance across all tiers.

TikTok's nano influencers (1K-10K followers) command engagement rates between 7.5% and 18.4%, significantly outperforming Instagram's 2.7-8.0% range for the same tier. This inverse relationship between follower count and engagement rate reflects audience intimacy and algorithm distribution patterns.

Micro influencers (10K-100K) on TikTok maintain 5.1-9.7% engagement compared to Instagram's 1.8-3.5%. The platform's algorithm doesn't heavily penalize accounts as they grow, unlike Instagram's declining organic reach for larger accounts. TikTok micro influencers typically receive 510-970 engagements per 10,000 followers, while Instagram micro influencers see 180-350 engagements.

Macro influencers (100K+) experience the smallest gap between platforms: TikTok's 2.9-4.5% versus Instagram's 0.6-1.9%. However, TikTok macro influencers still achieve 60% higher engagement rates. Comment-to-like ratios favor TikTok across all tiers, with comments comprising 15-20% of total engagements compared to Instagram's 8-12%.

If you're struggling to identify what content works in your niche, we can help you figure it out.

What's the typical conversion rate for creators selling products or services on each platform, and how does that split across digital products, physical goods, affiliate links, and sponsored content?

TikTok achieves 3.4% average conversion rates with superior impulse purchase behavior, while Instagram delivers 1.08% conversions but higher average order values.

Product Type	TikTok Conversion & Behavior	Instagram Conversion & Behavior
Digital Products	4.2% - Courses, ebooks, apps perform well with younger demographics	1.4% - Lower impulse buying for digital goods
Physical Goods	3.1% - Fashion, beauty, gadgets drive impulse purchases	0.9% - Higher consideration time, +35% AOV advantage
Affiliate Links	2.8% - Quick decision making, price-sensitive audience	0.8% - Longer research phase before purchase
Sponsored Content	3.7% - Authentic integration crucial, Gen Z trusts creators	1.2% - Polished ads perform, millennial audience skeptical
Services	2.9% - Consultations, coaching, local services	1.1% - Professional services, B2B offerings
Subscription Products	3.8% - Monthly boxes, app subscriptions, memberships	1.3% - Higher retention rates once converted

What are the key audience demographic differences between TikTok and Instagram—age, interests, behavior—and what kind of content do they engage with most on each?

TikTok skews toward 25-34 year-olds (35.3%) with high Gen Z penetration, while Instagram's largest segment remains 18-24 (31.7%) with broader millennial adoption.

Gen Z represents 82% of TikTok's weekly active users compared to 61% on Instagram, creating distinct content consumption patterns. TikTok users prefer authentic, unpolished content that feels spontaneous, while Instagram audiences gravitate toward curated, visually appealing posts that maintain aesthetic consistency.

Shopping motivation differs significantly: 77% of TikTok users discover products organically through their feed, leading to impulse purchases within the app. Instagram users research products more deliberately, with 61% planning purchases after initial discovery. TikTok's integrated shopping features reduce friction between discovery and purchase.

Content engagement patterns reveal TikTok users interact with educational content delivered in quick, digestible formats (60-second tutorials), while Instagram users engage with comprehensive educational content through carousel posts and longer-form captions. TikTok prioritizes entertainment value even in educational content, whereas Instagram audiences accept more formal, instructional approaches.

Behavioral data shows TikTok users spend 95 minutes daily on platform compared to Instagram's 53 minutes, but Instagram users demonstrate higher brand loyalty and return purchase rates once converted.

Which platform drives higher engagement for short-form video versus carousel posts, Reels, Stories, or Lives?

TikTok's native short-form videos achieve 2.5× higher engagement than Instagram Reels, while Instagram carousels outperform all other static content formats.

Instagram Reels average 1.23% engagement compared to TikTok's 2.50%, despite similar format and functionality. TikTok's algorithm aggressively promotes video content, while Instagram's algorithm must balance multiple content types. TikTok videos benefit from the platform's full-screen, sound-on experience that maximizes attention capture.

Instagram carousel posts maintain 0.55% engagement (down 15% year-over-year), still outperforming single image posts at 0.45%. Carousels work exceptionally well for step-by-step tutorials, before/after transformations, and product catalogs. Educational content achieves highest engagement through carousel format on Instagram.

Instagram Stories show declining engagement as the format matures, while TikTok doesn't offer comparable ephemeral content. Live streaming engagement varies significantly by creator size and niche, with both platforms showing similar performance for established creators. Instagram Live maintains slight advantage for Q&A sessions and product launches due to integrated shopping features.

Video content dominates both platforms, but optimal length differs: TikTok performs best with 15-30 second videos, while Instagram Reels achieve peak engagement at 7-15 seconds.

Which platform has more fake followers or bot traffic on average in 2025, and how does that impact engagement quality?

Instagram faces 60% projected fake follower growth by 2025, while TikTok shows lower bot density but detection remains challenging.

Instagram's mature ecosystem attracts more sophisticated bot networks, with fake followers comprising 15-25% of total followers for accounts over 100K. These bots typically engage through likes rather than comments, creating inflated engagement numbers without meaningful interaction. Authentic engagement rates drop significantly when accounting for bot activity.

TikTok's algorithm-driven discovery reduces reliance on follower counts, making fake followers less valuable for visibility. However, bot detection proves more difficult due to TikTok's opaque analytics and rapid content consumption patterns. Fake engagement often appears as immediate likes within seconds of posting, before human users could realistically view content.

Quality indicators reveal Instagram's bot problem: accounts with engagement rates below 1% combined with high follower counts typically indicate purchased followers. TikTok's engagement quality suffers from different issues—short attention spans mean high engagement doesn't always translate to conversion or brand recall.

Both platforms implement detection systems, but Instagram's longer history means more sophisticated circumvention methods exist. Brands increasingly audit influencer accounts for fake followers, with 73% requesting detailed analytics before partnerships.

Not sure why your posts aren't converting? Let us take a look for you.

How does spending behavior differ between users on TikTok and Instagram—where do people spend more money and through which features?

TikTok users spend impulsively through integrated shopping features, while Instagram users make planned purchases with 35% higher average order values.

TikTok Shop integration drives 67% impulse purchase rates, with users buying directly within the app during content consumption. Average order values remain lower ($45-75) but conversion rates triple Instagram's performance. TikTok's live shopping events generate significant revenue spikes, particularly for fashion and beauty products.

Instagram Shopping maintains higher transaction values ($85-125 average) through product catalogs and detailed descriptions. Users research products across multiple posts before purchasing, leading to more considered buying decisions. Instagram's checkout process requires leaving the platform, creating friction that reduces impulse purchases but increases buyer intent.

Subscription services perform better on TikTok due to younger demographics comfortable with recurring payments. Instagram drives higher-value service purchases like courses, consultations, and B2B offerings through professional presentation and longer content formats.

Payment preferences differ: TikTok users favor digital wallets and buy-now-pay-later options, while Instagram users use traditional payment methods more frequently. Creator monetization varies significantly, with TikTok's Creator Fund and live gifting providing immediate revenue, while Instagram's monetization requires larger followings but offers higher per-creator earnings.

What does the full conversion funnel look like for each platform, from reach to impressions, to clicks, to conversions—and what are the average metrics at each stage?

TikTok's algorithm-driven funnel achieves higher top-funnel metrics but Instagram maintains superior bottom-funnel conversion optimization.

Funnel Stage	TikTok Average Metrics	Instagram Average Metrics
Reach Rate	45-65% of followers reached organically	6.5% of followers reached organically
Impression Rate	2.3 impressions per reached user	1.8 impressions per reached user
Engagement Rate	2.50% average (likes, comments, shares)	0.50% average (likes, comments, saves)
Click-Through Rate	0.84% (bio links, in-video CTAs)	0.46% (bio links, story swipe-ups)
Conversion Rate	3.4% (purchase, signup, download)	1.08% (purchase, signup, download)
Cost Per Conversion	$12-18 (organic + minimal paid boost)	$28-45 (heavy reliance on paid promotion)
Customer Lifetime Value	$67 average (lower retention rates)	$156 average (higher retention, repeat purchases)

What are the biggest changes in engagement and reach for both TikTok and Instagram in 2025 compared to 2024?

Instagram's organic reach declined 28% year-over-year while TikTok maintained stable engagement despite increased competition.

Instagram's algorithm increasingly prioritizes paid content, reducing organic post visibility from 8.5% to 6.5% of followers. Reels engagement dropped from 1.72% to 1.23% as the format became oversaturated. The platform's focus on e-commerce integration created more friction for content creators not selling products directly.

TikTok faced challenges from increased creator competition but maintained engagement rates through algorithm improvements. The platform introduced longer video formats (up to 10 minutes) which initially confused the algorithm but now perform well for educational content. TikTok Shop integration boosted conversion metrics without significantly impacting organic reach.

Creator monetization shifted dramatically: Instagram reduced Creator Fund payouts while promoting Reels Play Bonus programs. TikTok expanded Creator Rewards globally but tightened eligibility requirements. Both platforms increased revenue sharing from live streaming and virtual gifts.

User behavior evolved with TikTok users spending more time on educational content (23% increase) while Instagram users shifted toward shopping-focused browsing. Cross-platform posting became less effective as each platform's algorithm increasingly favors native content creation.

What trends and engagement shifts are forecasted for TikTok and Instagram in 2026 across key niches?

Educational content will dominate TikTok growth while Instagram doubles down on shopping integration and creator monetization tools.

TikTok's educational content engagement is projected to increase 35% as the platform attracts older demographics seeking skill development and news. Finance, career advice, and tech tutorials will emerge as high-engagement niches. The platform will likely introduce longer-form content options competing directly with YouTube.

Instagram will prioritize shopping features with AR try-on capabilities and improved product discovery. Fashion and beauty niches will benefit from enhanced visual search and automated product tagging. The platform plans algorithm updates favoring accounts that drive sales, potentially reducing reach for non-commercial creators.

Live commerce will become crucial for both platforms, with TikTok leading adoption in Western markets following Asian success. Instagram will integrate more sophisticated analytics for business accounts and expand Reels monetization options. Both platforms will implement stricter creator verification to combat fake engagement.

Emerging niches include sustainability content, mental health discussions, and local business discovery. TikTok's algorithm will likely favor authentic, personal storytelling over highly produced content. Instagram will maintain focus on aesthetic appeal but introduce features supporting behind-the-scenes content.

If you feel like your content isn't getting enough engagement, we can help improve that.

Based on goals like community growth, product sales, or brand visibility, how should someone decide which platform to focus on?

Choose TikTok for rapid audience growth and Gen Z engagement, Instagram for monetization and professional brand building.

Community growth strategies differ significantly between platforms. TikTok's algorithm provides immediate exposure for quality content regardless of follower count, making it ideal for rapid audience acquisition. New accounts can achieve viral reach within days, while Instagram requires consistent posting over months to build visibility. TikTok users follow accounts more readily after single video interactions.

Product sales performance depends on target demographics and purchase behavior. TikTok excels for impulse purchases under $100, particularly beauty, fashion, and digital products targeting younger consumers. Instagram drives higher-value sales through detailed product showcases and customer testimonials, making it superior for luxury goods, services, and B2B offerings.

Brand visibility goals require platform-specific approaches. TikTok builds awareness through entertainment and authenticity, while Instagram establishes credibility through professional presentation and user-generated content. B2B brands typically achieve better results on Instagram through thought leadership content and professional networking.

Resource allocation should consider content creation requirements: TikTok demands frequent posting (1-3 times daily) with trend-responsive content, while Instagram allows for higher production value with less frequent posting (3-5 times weekly). Budget constraints favor TikTok's organic reach over Instagram's pay-to-play model.

Long-term strategy suggests hybrid approaches: use TikTok for top-funnel awareness and audience discovery, then retarget engaged users through Instagram for conversion optimization and customer relationship building.

Conclusion

Sources

1. Social Insider - Social Media Benchmarks
2. Social Insider - Instagram vs TikTok Analysis
3. Sprout Social - TikTok Statistics
4. The Social Cat - Influencer Marketing Report
5. Shopify - Social Media Conversion Rates
6. Enhencer - Instagram Reels vs TikTok ROI
7. Phyllo - Instagram Demographics
8. Socialbook - TikTok vs Instagram Sales 2025
9. Talkwalker - Social Media Statistics
10. Sprout Social - Social Media Demographics

Who is the author of this content?

NAPOLIFY

A team specialized in data-driven growth strategies for social media

We offer data-driven, battle-tested approach to growing online profiles, especially on platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook. Unlike traditional agencies or consultants who often recycle generic advice,we go on the field and we keep analyzing real-world social content—breaking down hundreds of viral posts to identify what formats, hooks, and strategies actually drive engagement, conversions, and growth. If you'd like to learn more about us, you can check our website.

How this content was created 🔎📝

At Napolify, we analyze social media trends and viral content every day. Our team doesn't just observe from a distance—we're actively studying platform-specific patterns, breaking down viral posts, and maintaining a constantly updated database of trends, tactics, and strategies. This hands-on approach allows us to understand what actually drives engagement and growth.

These observations are originally based on what we've learned through analyzing hundreds of viral posts and real-world performance data. But it was not enough. To back them up, we also needed to rely on trusted resources and case studies from major brands.

We prioritize accuracy and authority. Trends lacking solid data or performance metrics were excluded.

Trustworthiness is central to our work. Every source and citation is clearly listed, ensuring transparency. A writing AI-powered tool was used solely to refine readability and engagement.

To make the information accessible, our team designed custom infographics that clarify key points. We hope you will like them! All illustrations and media were created in-house and added manually.