Today, do you get a better reach on Instagram or on Pinterest?
This article has been written by our Instagram expert who will tell you what are the most efficient strategies in your niche
We will tell you what works for your niche on social media
Pinterest delivers higher reach rates and better commercial intent than Instagram, especially for accounts under 10K followers.
While Instagram excels at real-time engagement and viral spikes, Pinterest drives more sustainable organic traffic and conversion rates that outperform Instagram across most niches. The data from 2025 shows Pinterest's evergreen content model consistently beats Instagram's declining organic reach for long-term growth.
And if you need help with your social media, our team can take a look and help you grow more efficiently.
Summary
Pinterest outperforms Instagram in reach rates, conversion potential, and long-term traffic generation, making it the superior choice for most business goals in 2025.
| Metric | ||
|---|---|---|
| Average Reach Rate | 3.5% overall, 8% for small accounts with Reels | 1.65% but with evergreen visibility lasting months |
| Click-Through Rate | 0.5-1% for ads, lower for organic content | 1.68% organic, 1-2% for ads with higher intent |
| Conversion Rate | Variable, 46% boost with influencer content | 1.85% average with luxury/home niches performing higher |
| Best Content Type | Short Reels under 15 seconds with quick hooks | Vertical pins 1000x1500px with keyword optimization |
| Algorithm Focus 2025 | 3-second retention hooks, DMs and shares priority | Fresh keyword-optimized content, spam penalties |
| Organic Traffic Potential | Declining without constant adaptation | Superior for new accounts, sustainable growth |
| Best For | Brand awareness, community building, viral spikes | Traffic generation, sales conversions, long-term growth |
What's the current average reach rate per post on Instagram vs. Pinterest for accounts under 10K, 10K–100K, and over 100K followers?
Pinterest delivers consistently higher reach rates for smaller accounts, while Instagram's reach advantage diminishes as account size grows.
| Account Size | Instagram Reach Rate | Pinterest Reach Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Under 10K followers | 8% for Reels, 2-3% for static posts | Higher virality potential, no size barriers |
| 10K-100K followers | 4-6% for Reels, 1.5-2% for posts | Consistent 1.65% but evergreen discovery |
| Over 100K followers | 4% average, declining without viral content | Stable reach with SEO-optimized pins |
| Content Lifespan | 24-48 hours maximum visibility | Months to years of ongoing discovery |
| Algorithm Preference | Favors accounts with high recent engagement | Rewards quality content regardless of account size |
| Peak Performance Window | First 3 hours after posting | Can peak weeks or months after posting |
| Growth Difficulty | Increasingly difficult as account grows | Consistent growth potential at all sizes |
What's the typical engagement rate on Instagram versus Pinterest by niche?
Instagram engagement varies dramatically by niche, with fitness leading at 2.5% while beauty has declined 30% year-over-year to just 0.5%.
Pinterest maintains steadier engagement around 0.25-0.3% overall, but excels in visual niches like home decor and DIY where commercial intent runs high. The platform's 0.99% rate for micro-influencers on Instagram drops significantly for larger accounts, while Pinterest's engagement remains stable regardless of follower count.
If you're struggling to identify what content works in your niche, we can help you figure it out.
How many likes and comments does an average post get on each platform by account size?
Instagram generates 5,409 impressions per Reel for 100K+ accounts, but engagement metrics focus heavily on vanity metrics like likes and comments.
Pinterest operates differently, prioritizing saves and outbound clicks over surface-level engagement. A Pinterest user who saves your content shows higher purchase intent than someone who simply likes an Instagram post. Pinterest users earning over $100K annually represent one in three users, indicating superior audience quality for business objectives.
Instagram's visible metrics can mislead creators into optimizing for engagement rather than conversions, while Pinterest's save-focused model directly correlates with purchasing behavior and website traffic generation.
What's the click-through rate and conversion rate when promoting products on each platform?
Pinterest significantly outperforms Instagram in both click-through rates and conversions across all revenue streams.
| Revenue Stream | Instagram Performance | Pinterest Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Affiliate Links | 0.5-1% CTR, 16% of e-commerce sales | 1.68% CTR, higher intent targeting luxury/home |
| Digital Products | Requires influencer partnerships for effectiveness | Direct sales through organic pins, evergreen traffic |
| Service Promotion | 46% sales boost with user-generated content | 1.85% conversion rate, lower cost per click |
| Brand Partnerships | $0.40-$1.73 cost per click for ads | Lower CPC than Meta ads, higher commercial intent |
| E-commerce Integration | Shopping tags available but limited organic reach | Product Rich Pins drive direct product discovery |
| Lead Generation | Effective for B2C with video testimonials | Superior for DIY, home improvement, luxury services |
| Long-term ROI | Requires constant content creation and ad spend | Evergreen content continues driving conversions |
Which platform brings more organic traffic without paid ads for new accounts starting from scratch?
Pinterest dominates organic traffic generation for new accounts, offering sustainable growth without requiring paid promotion.
New Pinterest accounts can achieve consistent traffic within weeks through keyword-optimized pins that continue driving visitors for months or years. The platform's search-based discovery model means quality content gets found regardless of follower count, making it ideal for bootstrapped businesses.
Instagram's algorithm heavily favors established accounts with existing engagement, making organic growth increasingly difficult for newcomers. New Instagram accounts face significant barriers to reach, often requiring viral Reels or paid promotion to gain initial traction.
Pinterest content from 2024 continues generating traffic in 2025, while Instagram Reels typically lose visibility within 24-48 hours, requiring constant content creation to maintain reach.
Not sure why your posts aren't converting? Let us take a look for you.
How has the organic reach and algorithm changed on both platforms in 2025?
Instagram's 2025 algorithm prioritizes 3-second retention hooks and tests content with non-follower audiences, while Pinterest emphasizes fresh, keyword-optimized content with strict spam penalties.
Instagram now rewards DMs, shares, and saves over simple likes, pushing creators toward more interactive content formats. The platform increasingly favors Reels that capture attention within three seconds, making hook creation crucial for reach.
Pinterest's algorithm downgrades repetitive or spammy pins while promoting fresh content with proper keyword optimization. The platform's AI tools like Performance Plus automatically optimize ad campaigns, making paid promotion more accessible for small businesses.
Both platforms prioritize quality over quantity, but Instagram demands constant adaptation to trending formats while Pinterest rewards consistent, SEO-focused content creation that builds long-term authority.
How many bots or fake accounts typically engage on each platform, and how does it affect real analytics?
Instagram suffers from approximately 10% fake accounts that inflate engagement metrics, while Pinterest maintains cleaner data through regular purges of fake followers.
Instagram's bot problem significantly skews analytics, making it difficult to assess true engagement and audience quality. Fake likes and comments can mislead creators about content performance and audience preferences, leading to misguided strategy decisions.
Pinterest's lower bot activity means more reliable performance data, allowing creators to make better-informed decisions about content strategy and audience targeting. The platform's focus on search and discovery rather than follower counts reduces the incentive for fake account creation.
This data quality difference makes Pinterest metrics more trustworthy for business planning and ROI calculations, while Instagram requires additional tools and analysis to filter out artificial engagement.
Where do users spend the most time per session and how does that influence content visibility?
Instagram users spend 33.1 minutes daily browsing content, with Gen Z users averaging 53 minutes, while Pinterest sessions last only 2 minutes 11 seconds but total 1 hour 49 minutes monthly.
Instagram's longer session times favor immersive content like Reels and Stories that can capture sustained attention, making it ideal for entertainment and community-building content that encourages binge-watching behaviors.
Pinterest's shorter but more frequent sessions suit quick inspiration gathering, where users save content for later action. This behavior pattern makes Pinterest more effective for planning purchases, project ideas, and future reference content.
The session length difference means Instagram content needs immediate engagement to succeed, while Pinterest content can gradually build momentum through repeated discovery and saves over time.
If you feel like your content isn't getting enough engagement, we can help improve that.
What kind of content performs best on each platform and how does it affect reach?
Short Reels under 15 seconds with immediate hooks achieve 22% higher engagement than static posts on Instagram, while Pinterest favors vertical pins at 1000x1500 pixels optimized for mobile discovery.
| Content Format | Instagram Performance | Pinterest Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Video Content | Reels under 15s perform best, requires trending audio | Idea Pins with tutorials drive highest click-through |
| Static Images | Declining reach, carousels slightly better | Vertical pins with text overlay perform excellently |
| Educational Content | Behind-scenes tutorials generate high saves | Step-by-step guides with keywords dominate search |
| Product Showcases | Requires authentic testimonials for credibility | Lifestyle images with products in context work best |
| Seasonal Content | Must align with real-time trends and hashtags | Evergreen seasonal content performs year-round |
| Text-Heavy Posts | Quote graphics with branded templates | Tip lists and infographics drive high saves |
| User-Generated Content | Essential for authenticity and social proof | Testimonials with results photos convert well |
Which platform gives better performance for long-term growth vs. short-term viral spikes?
Pinterest excels at long-term sustainable growth while Instagram dominates short-term viral potential, but Instagram's spikes fade quickly without constant content adaptation.
Instagram Reels can generate massive reach within hours but typically lose visibility within 24-48 hours, requiring creators to constantly produce trending content to maintain momentum. The platform's algorithm heavily favors recent content, making consistent posting essential for sustained reach.
Pinterest content builds momentum gradually but continues driving traffic for months or years after posting. A well-optimized pin from 2024 can still generate significant traffic in 2025, creating compounding returns on content investment that Instagram cannot match.
For businesses seeking sustainable growth, Pinterest's evergreen model provides better ROI through reduced content creation requirements and consistent traffic generation, while Instagram suits brands prioritizing immediate awareness and trending relevance.
How does the full conversion funnel compare from reach to sale for Instagram vs. Pinterest?
Pinterest outperforms Instagram in click-through rates and commercial intent, while Instagram excels in initial reach and brand awareness generation.
| Funnel Stage | Instagram Performance | Pinterest Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Awareness (Reach) | 3.5% average reach, 8% for small account Reels | 1.65% average but evergreen discovery potential |
| Interest (Engagement) | Likes and comments, nano-influencers win | Saves and clicks indicate higher purchase intent |
| Consideration (Click) | 0.5-1% click-through rate for promoted content | 1.68% organic CTR with superior intent quality |
| Purchase (Sale) | 46% boost with influencer partnerships | 1.85% average conversion, luxury niches higher |
| Retention | Community building through DMs and comments | Boards create ongoing customer touchpoints |
| Advocacy | User-generated content and testimonials | Sharing boards and product recommendations |
| Long-term Value | Requires ongoing engagement and content | Evergreen content continues converting customers |
Based on goals like traffic, sales, brand awareness, or community building, how should one choose between Instagram and Pinterest in 2025?
Choose Pinterest for traffic generation and sales conversions, Instagram for brand awareness and community building, but Pinterest delivers superior ROI for most business objectives in 2025.
Pinterest's search-based discovery model makes it ideal for businesses prioritizing website traffic, lead generation, and direct sales. The platform's high-intent audience and evergreen content model provide sustainable growth with lower ongoing effort requirements.
Instagram excels in visual storytelling, real-time community engagement, and brand personality development through Stories, DMs, and interactive features. Choose Instagram when building brand awareness, showcasing company culture, or developing direct customer relationships.
For resource-limited businesses, Pinterest offers better returns through its evergreen content model and higher conversion rates. Instagram requires more intensive content creation and community management but provides superior tools for building brand loyalty and customer relationships.
Don't know which format works best for your audience? We can help you test and optimize.
Conclusion
Pinterest consistently outperforms Instagram in 2025 for reach rates, conversion potential, and sustainable organic growth, making it the superior choice for most business objectives.
While Instagram excels at community building and viral spikes, Pinterest's evergreen content model, higher commercial intent, and better click-through rates deliver more reliable returns for businesses seeking long-term growth and sales generation.
Sources
- Social Insider - Social Media Reach
- Sprout Social - Instagram Stats
- Adam Connell - Pinterest Statistics
- Mad Pin Media - Pinterest Marketing Worth
- Red Website Design - Social Engagement Trends
- Cropink - Instagram Advertising Cost
- Hostinger - Affiliate Marketing Statistics
- Metricool - Pinterest Engagement
- Lolly Said Yes - Pinterest Traffic 2025
- Stack Influence - Instagram Algorithm 2025
Read more articles
-Engagement Rate Instagram vs YouTube
-Conversion Rate Instagram vs YouTube
-Better Reach Instagram vs Facebook
